Kinderpack Vs Tula: Which Is The Best Baby Carrier For You?

Mumeemagic is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The right baby carrier can make all the difference when transporting our kids around They are a secure, comfortable way to take some of the strain while allowing our children to be close to us at all times. The best options are also pretty practical and have great designs too. But it isn’t always that easy to find the ideal product. They are often either too small, too uncomfortable, or just a pain to use.


Kinderpack Vs Tula: the battle of the baby carriers.


In this guide, I want to compare the Tula baby carrier to another similar option called the Kinderpack. Personally, I prefer the Tula model and I will explain why in a moment. But, there are lots of similarities between the two, and both have their beneficial features. I will discuss how the two compare when it comes to key factors like their comfort, capacity, extra features, general convenience for parents, design, and affordability. In the end, hopefully, you will have a better idea of which one to choose.


The Tula baby carrier is a comfortable choice with lots of helpful features.


Tula Baby CarrierCheck on Amazon 


It is hard to find anything negative about the Tula baby carrier. There are some parents that say it isn’t the most comfortable they have tried, but there is still plenty of padding and nice use of breathable mesh in some designs. The reason that I like the Tula model so much because it gives parents more options. The infant insert for newborns is a stand-out feature, and other aspects like the machine-washable design and hood help too. There are also lots of patterns and some alternative models if you need to upgrade.

That doesn’t mean that the Kinderpack doesn’t have its benefits too.

These products are very similar in their shape and purpose. You get the same sort of structure for carrying kids on your front or your back. There are also similarities in the features used for added convenience. This one doesn’t have an option for newborns. That is why it isn’t my personal pick. Instead, you have to upgrade to this carrier as kids get a little older It is also a bit more expensive. But, there are suggestions that one is more comfortable for parents and it is still a high-quality choice.

The capacity and suitability of these baby carriers for newborns and older babies.

Let’s start with the issue of capacity and suitability for newborn babies. This is the biggest difference between the two products and the potential deal-breaker for a lot of parents.

It is important to look at the size of any baby carrier to make sure that they are going to be a good fit. You can start with the weight allowance. There should be a strong construction that allows for older babies without too much strain. The size of the carrier should also reflect this age range. But, there is the risk that bigger carriers won’t be secure enough for younger babies.


Is the Tula baby carrier suitable for newborns?

Yes, the standard baby carrier is suitable for newborns if you use the newborn insert. This feature, sold separately, changes the internal dimensions for a more secure fit. What this then means is that you can use the same carrier for longer. This is perfect if you find a design you love and if the product ends up as a comfortable, durable choice for you.

I also want to note at this point that there are alternative models of baby carriers available from Tula. This review focuses on the standard, as this is the one I feel most new parents will look at first. But, there are also other choices like the toddler and explore. Many of these also allow for newborn carrying and different positions, so check them out.


What is the Tula baby weight limit?

Tula claims that the weight allowance on the standard carrier is 15 to 60 pounds. This means that you can start quite young, even without the insert, and should be able to keep using this product when babies are a lot older. This is great for toddlers that are a little bigger than average or those struggling with the idea of not being carried anymore.


What about the capacity of the Kinderpack?

Kinderpack does things a little differently. There are four models in their range based on the size of the child, rather than the style of the carrier. They are Infant, Standard, Toddler, and Pre-school. The idea is that you start with the Infant and work your way up through the sizes as you need them. This isn’t going to work for parents that want a one-size-fits-all approach with one durable, affordable solution. But, it does mean you can get a new design and a strong, reliable system for each stage.

This Kinderpack Vs Tula review focuses on the standard baby carrier, for the same reasons as the Tula model. As you might expect given this size range, the weight capacity is more restricted. Here the lower limit is 20 pounds and the upper limit 40. This is still great for a lot of babies and the carrier is nice and strong.


Which of these baby carriers is the most comfortable?

Comfort is essential for both mother and baby, especially on long days and in hot weather. There is always the risk here that the straps might be too tight or start digging in under the arms. We also have to consider the feel of the materials and padding for children sitting in these things for long periods.

Parent reviews for the Kinderpack suggest that this is the best choice when it comes to a more comfortable solution for parents. But, there are features within the Tula carrier that are also appealing for babies.


Why is the Kinderpack so comfortable for parents?

One of the reasons that parents love the Kinderpack so much is the attention towards comfort and support for long-term use. This product is made for use on either your front or your back, giving you the chance to work around your day and the needs of your child. There is plenty of padding on the carrier and straps for comfort, and this continues with the firm waistband. There is no sense that this will dig into your arms or rib or start to become uncomfortable with time.

A big part of this is the use of straps. Not only are the straps highly adjustable, but you also get two lengths to choose from. This allows for a more secure and comfortable fit that will give parents greater peace of mind. This adaptability also means it is more likely for both parents t find the best fit and wear this with ease.

As for the kids, they should have no problem getting comfortable here because of the quality of the padding and the secure fit. The benefit of a size-based system like this is that you know it is for children of their age – so should be more snug and comforting for them. In fact, there are parents that say their children fall asleep very quickly in these carriers. The use of mesh panels on some of the designs helps too for ventilation in hotter weather.


What about the Tula carrier?

There are a lot of positive comments about the Tula carrier. It is still a comfortable option and the use of 100% cotton materials is a definite bonus. There is padding for your child and a little on the straps, but not as much as on the Kinderpack. Also, the bigger age range means that it could get a little gappy for some babies without that comforting compression that they might otherwise enjoy. There are also comments from parents that the straps aren’t as adjustable as they could be.


How does the Coast Tula baby carrier help kids on hotter days?


Another interesting part of the Tula range is the Coast series. When you browse the different patterns and colors available, you should see that there are choices between the standard or the coast. What this means is that you get a large mesh panel on the carrier for extra ventilation. This does detract from the look of the carrier, as it breaks up the print, but it could make a big difference for sunnier days or foreign travel – which explains the name.

Both carriers have extra features that are highly convenient and will appeal to parents.

Comfort and capacity aren’t everything when it comes to finding the best possible baby carrier for your child. It also helps to have extra protective features, storage, and other aspects that make life easier for us parents. That is why it helps to look beyond the dimensions and materials used to see what else these products can do for us. Are you going to be able to use this with ease or get frustrated with it by the end of the day? This is where the Kinderpack Vs Tula debate gets more interesting.


What extra features does the Tula baby carrier have that makes it so popular with parents?

This is another way that the Tula stands out as a parent-friendly choice. There are some interesting extra features with convenience and ease of use in mind. One of these is the removable hood. This is a nice touch for a little extra sun protection on hotter days, or perhaps a way to deal with light rain showers.

There is also a little storage pocket in the waist. You aren’t going to get a lot in there, but it is better than nothing. Finally, there is the fact that this option is machine washable. This can make a big difference if there are ever any major accidents or spills.


Can you breastfeed in a Tula carrier?

Yes, you can. The design of the Tula baby carrier is nursing friendly. Therefore, it shouldn’t be too much hassle to wear this carrier comfortably and securely while providing the next feed for your child. This is perfect for parents that perhaps weren’t sure about using baby carriers while breastfeeding. Another benefit here is that each of the different Tula models in the wider range also has this feature. So, if you wanted to upgrade to the Explore or another system, you could do so.


Does the Kinderpack share any of these features?

By comparison, the Kinderpack doesn’t seem to have as many features onboard. There is no sign of a hood or other protective feature, which suggests that this isn’t as ready for a change in the weather. There is also no mention of any storage solution or if the product is machine washable. It is easy to assume that you could wash this. But, the official website is a little short on information. As a result, this one doesn’t seem to be quite as parent-friendly beyond all those helpful comfort features.


What about the design of these baby carriers?

It is also nice to have an attractive design on these carriers if you are going to carry them around for so long. There is nothing wrong with looking at these products like another accessory. This is something that you wear and it is prominent. The design of a backpack would be a big factor when buying one of those. So, don’t be afraid to take your time looking at the different patterns and colors available. The good news is that these brands offer a lot of choices, some with parents in mind and others that are more child-friendly.

Tula offers some great examples of patterns and designs that are stylish and geared towards the parent. Some are quite subtle with floral or geometric approaches. There are also some great coastal themes to go with the Coast mesh design. The jellyfish one is particularly sweet. But, there are also some really nice options with kids in mind. These include the Land before Tula option, with its cute dinosaur print.

Another great thing about the Tula designs is that they have a signature range. Here you get some really pretty woven fabrics that are a lot of fun and don’t look like other mass-produced baby carriers.


Kinderpack offers something a little different.

Personally, I think the Kinderpack designs are a lot more fun and designed with the kids in mind. But, I appreciate that they might be too bold for some parents. Key examples here are the multicolored Elephant romp, Big Bang science-themed carrier, and the Princess party. Nerdier parents will love the Doctor Who and Star Wars-themed options too. Or, there are more gentle nature-themed ones like Bear Mountain and Whale Tales.

I also want to mention here that Kinderpack has taken the time to add facemasks to their range – taking advantage of some great prints. I can only assume that this will continue for as long as this situation with Covid continues. It is a nice additional option for the safety of our families. At the time of writing this, they were also selling Halloween face masks for safer trick-or-treating.


Are these baby carriers affordable?

This final point is just as important for parents that are on a budget. It doesn’t matter how amazing a product is if it is out of your price range. There are two factors here that I need to highlight. The first is that the Tula standard carrier is a little cheaper at around $139, compared to the $174 of the Kinderpack. That’s $35 that could go on other accessories, diapers, or a lot more. Also, Tula does discount some of their designs from time to time.

The other factor is availability. Both companies have great online stores where you can find different designs and options. But, it can be harder to find the Kinderpack on secondary online retailers.


Is Tula the best baby carrier?


When we weigh up the different pros and cons of these products, it is a pretty close race. They share so many beneficial features and design ideas that it is difficult to separate them. On one side, you have an attractive, larger Kinderpack that is great for growing children and that has some helpful comfort features. But, it is also unsuitable from birth and more expensive. The Tula, on the other hand, is more affordable and does have that insert, making it more adaptable. This makes it a more accessible choice for a lot of parents. But, it doesn’t offer quite as much comfort.


Kinderpack vs Tula: which is right for you?


In the end, the choice really is down to you. If you are looking for affordability and long-term use then the Tula baby carrier is a great option. But, there is no reason why you can’t spend a little more on the Kinderpack if it is within budget and you prefer the idea of the style and comfort features. Don’t forget that there are also the alternative types of carriers from these brands, so take your time to browse and Amazon has some great choices when it comes to Tula. There is a great chance that one of these options will be right for you and your child.



This post is written and edited by Sandy who is a clinical pharmacist with over 20 years of experience specializing in pre-natal and post-natal care.